LITTLE TRAVERSE HISTORY MUSEUM
  • Home
  • Calendar of Events
    • Bike Fest
    • Corn Roast
    • Picnic on the Porch
  • Virtual Visit
    • 1903 Map Project
    • Woods and Water Vacation 1908 Scrapbook
    • Milkweed
    • A Century of Fashion
    • Woman Suffrage in Petoskey
    • Women's Federated Clubs
    • Women's Club
    • Art Study Club
    • Curtis Park Club
    • Assembly Study Club
    • School History
    • The de Jaffa Collection
    • Videos
  • Collections
  • 50 Years/50 Stories
    • 106 East Mitchell Street
    • Bay View Inn
    • Bear River Valley Heritage Center
    • Birkett House
    • Breakwall
    • The Brewery
    • Bruce Catton Plaque
    • Burns Clinic
    • Camp Daggett
    • Carnegie Library
    • Central School
    • Chicago and West Michigan Depot
    • City Park Grill
    • The Clock Tower
    • Crooked Tree Arts Center
    • Curtis Park
    • Emmet County Fairgrounds
    • Farragut's Cannon
    • Gaslight District
    • Grand Rapids and Indiana Depot
    • Greenwood Cemetery
    • Greenwood Cemetery Vault
    • Historic District Designation
    • Hollywood Theater Sign
    • Hospitals
    • Ice House
    • Ingalls Grocery
    • J.B. John Lifeboat
    • JC Penney Sign
    • Lockwood Park
    • Mackinac Trail Marker
    • Magnus Park
    • Masonic Temple
    • Meyer Hardware
    • Milkweed Project
    • Mineral Well Park
    • Mitchell Street Bridge
    • Normal College
    • Old Town Emmet
    • Parr Memorial Baptist Church
    • Perry Hotel
    • Petoskey Brewery
    • Petoskey Hospital
    • Railroad Tracks in Pennsylvania Park
    • Reid Furniture
    • Reusch Jewelers
    • Sheridan School Arch
    • Seibert Family Homestead
    • St Francis Solanus Mission Church
    • St. Francis Xavier Church
    • St. Francis Xavier School
    • Temple B'nai Israel
    • West Side Rink
    • Winter Sports Park
    • Zipp Building
    • Zoo
  • HIstoric People
    • Charles Beahan
    • Barbara Kellogg Blackmore
    • Joseph C. Bontecou
    • Dorinda Bowman
    • James Buckley
    • Clay Call
    • Alma Audrey Cessar
    • Jeanne Caskey Chichester
    • Leon Chichester
    • George W. Childs
    • C. Edson Churchill
    • Margaret Hankey Curtis
    • Edna Danser
    • George Danser
    • Lou S. Darling
    • Alice C. Erwin
    • Ethel Rowan Fasquelle
    • John L. Ferris
    • Frank Fochtman
    • Ellen Gillespie
    • Irene Gordon
    • Dr. Charles Gray
    • Christopher F. Hankey
    • Hazen Ingalls
    • Amelia Kaden
    • John Keep
    • Maggie Kellogg, M.D.
    • Harriet Kilborn
    • Elizabeth Stokes Krauser
    • Gwen Malloy
    • George W. McCabe
    • William G. McCune
    • William L. McManus, Jr.
    • Frances Pailthorp
    • Ella Petoskey
    • Ignatius Petoskey
    • Jean Liberty Pickett
    • Reverend John Redpath
    • Dr. George Reycraft
    • Dr. John Reycraft
    • Hiram O. Rose
    • Leila Rowan
    • Flavel Smith
    • Isaac Toll
    • John E. Walrond
    • Albert T. Washburne Sr.
    • Albert T. Washburne Jr
    • John W. Weaver
    • Elizabeth Whitney Williams
    • Dr. William Williams
    • Clara Wingate
  • Walking Tours
  • Kids' Programs
  • Contact
  • Media Connections
  • Research
  • Newsletter
  • Lasting Legacies
  • Donations
  • Hemingway
  • Education
  • About
  • SHOP
    • Rental
  • History
  • Directors' Blog
  • Board Members and Staff
  • Elfrida de Jaffa Travelogues

City Park Grill

Picture

432 E. Lake Street

City Park Grill, one of Petoskey's oldest buildings, was originally constructed in 1875. McCarty Hall, as it was known, was a males only billiard parlor that offered cigars and intoxicating beverages. In 1888 the building was purchased by Frank Gruelich. It was then called The Annex and provided dining and entertainment to guests of the adjacent Cushman Hotel. The 32 foot solid mahogany bar was installed at that time. Eleven years later, in 1897, Frank Fochtman took over the business. He expanded the business and built the Grill Cafe which opened in 1910 with a bowling alley in the basement. 

Young Ernest Hemingway, whose family summered on Walloon Lake, became a frequent guest, often sitting in the second seat from the end of the bar.

By 1932, the business was named the Park Garden Cafe and for the next 50+ years it saw a succession of owners. In 1997, the current owners purchased the site. It is now known as City Park Grill.
(City Park Grill website and Up North Days of Yore)

  • Home
  • Calendar of Events
    • Bike Fest
    • Corn Roast
    • Picnic on the Porch
  • Virtual Visit
    • 1903 Map Project
    • Woods and Water Vacation 1908 Scrapbook
    • Milkweed
    • A Century of Fashion
    • Woman Suffrage in Petoskey
    • Women's Federated Clubs
    • Women's Club
    • Art Study Club
    • Curtis Park Club
    • Assembly Study Club
    • School History
    • The de Jaffa Collection
    • Videos
  • Collections
  • 50 Years/50 Stories
    • 106 East Mitchell Street
    • Bay View Inn
    • Bear River Valley Heritage Center
    • Birkett House
    • Breakwall
    • The Brewery
    • Bruce Catton Plaque
    • Burns Clinic
    • Camp Daggett
    • Carnegie Library
    • Central School
    • Chicago and West Michigan Depot
    • City Park Grill
    • The Clock Tower
    • Crooked Tree Arts Center
    • Curtis Park
    • Emmet County Fairgrounds
    • Farragut's Cannon
    • Gaslight District
    • Grand Rapids and Indiana Depot
    • Greenwood Cemetery
    • Greenwood Cemetery Vault
    • Historic District Designation
    • Hollywood Theater Sign
    • Hospitals
    • Ice House
    • Ingalls Grocery
    • J.B. John Lifeboat
    • JC Penney Sign
    • Lockwood Park
    • Mackinac Trail Marker
    • Magnus Park
    • Masonic Temple
    • Meyer Hardware
    • Milkweed Project
    • Mineral Well Park
    • Mitchell Street Bridge
    • Normal College
    • Old Town Emmet
    • Parr Memorial Baptist Church
    • Perry Hotel
    • Petoskey Brewery
    • Petoskey Hospital
    • Railroad Tracks in Pennsylvania Park
    • Reid Furniture
    • Reusch Jewelers
    • Sheridan School Arch
    • Seibert Family Homestead
    • St Francis Solanus Mission Church
    • St. Francis Xavier Church
    • St. Francis Xavier School
    • Temple B'nai Israel
    • West Side Rink
    • Winter Sports Park
    • Zipp Building
    • Zoo
  • HIstoric People
    • Charles Beahan
    • Barbara Kellogg Blackmore
    • Joseph C. Bontecou
    • Dorinda Bowman
    • James Buckley
    • Clay Call
    • Alma Audrey Cessar
    • Jeanne Caskey Chichester
    • Leon Chichester
    • George W. Childs
    • C. Edson Churchill
    • Margaret Hankey Curtis
    • Edna Danser
    • George Danser
    • Lou S. Darling
    • Alice C. Erwin
    • Ethel Rowan Fasquelle
    • John L. Ferris
    • Frank Fochtman
    • Ellen Gillespie
    • Irene Gordon
    • Dr. Charles Gray
    • Christopher F. Hankey
    • Hazen Ingalls
    • Amelia Kaden
    • John Keep
    • Maggie Kellogg, M.D.
    • Harriet Kilborn
    • Elizabeth Stokes Krauser
    • Gwen Malloy
    • George W. McCabe
    • William G. McCune
    • William L. McManus, Jr.
    • Frances Pailthorp
    • Ella Petoskey
    • Ignatius Petoskey
    • Jean Liberty Pickett
    • Reverend John Redpath
    • Dr. George Reycraft
    • Dr. John Reycraft
    • Hiram O. Rose
    • Leila Rowan
    • Flavel Smith
    • Isaac Toll
    • John E. Walrond
    • Albert T. Washburne Sr.
    • Albert T. Washburne Jr
    • John W. Weaver
    • Elizabeth Whitney Williams
    • Dr. William Williams
    • Clara Wingate
  • Walking Tours
  • Kids' Programs
  • Contact
  • Media Connections
  • Research
  • Newsletter
  • Lasting Legacies
  • Donations
  • Hemingway
  • Education
  • About
  • SHOP
    • Rental
  • History
  • Directors' Blog
  • Board Members and Staff
  • Elfrida de Jaffa Travelogues